Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence #2020

Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence By David Benatar Better Never to Have Been The Harm of Coming into Existence Better Never to Have Been argues for a number of related highly provocative views Coming into existence is always a serious harm It is always wrong to have children It is wrong not to abort fe
  • Title: Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence
  • Author: David Benatar
  • ISBN: 9780199296422
  • Page: 126
  • Format: Hardcover
  • Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence By David Benatar Better Never to Have Been argues for a number of related, highly provocative, views 1 Coming into existence is always a serious harm 2 It is always wrong to have children 3 It is wrong not to abort fetuses at the earlier stages of gestation 4 It would be better if, as a result of there being no new people, humanity became extinct These views may sound unbelievBetter Never to Have Been argues for a number of related, highly provocative, views 1 Coming into existence is always a serious harm 2 It is always wrong to have children 3 It is wrong not to abort fetuses at the earlier stages of gestation 4 It would be better if, as a result of there being no new people, humanity became extinct These views may sound unbelievable but anyone who reads Benatar will be obliged to take them seriously.
    Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence By David Benatar
    • BEST AZW "↠ Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence" || DOWNLOAD (PDF) Ë
      David Benatar

    About "David Benatar"

    1. David Benatar

      David Benatar Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence book, this is one of the most wanted David Benatar author readers around the world.

    795 thoughts on “Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence”

    1. My girlfriend was on the fence about having an abortion so I picked up a copy of this here shit right here, had her read it and VOILA Fetus Deletus This shit is magic and I recommend all sexually active males retain a copy

    2. Seldom will you find a philosopher who can write this well for laypersons with the courage to advance such a counterintuitive thesis While people may find Benatar s conclusion repugnant i.e coming into existence is always a harm and extinction of the human race should be desired end , it is exceedingly difficult to find any flaw in his logic This is a great piece of work and philosphically sound While it may have been better that Benatar had never been, I am sure glad that he is being.

    3. Mr Benatar sticks it out alone In the face of religion and base natural drives he argues that there is nothing intrinsically good about procreation He goes even further than that and, striking repulsion in the faces most potential and actual parents, denouncing them as playing Russian roulette with a fully loaded gun aimed, of course, not at their own heads, but at those of their future offspring.The book is not without it s problems, of course If the topic does not scare off most of the readers [...]

    4. As noted on the blurb of this book, Benatar defends a view that almost no one accepts coming into existence is always a serious harm Indeed, though he doesn t state it in these terms, his conclusions hold not just for the actual world, but also entail that, for any logically possible world, coming into existence is at best morally neutral These ideas are based off a commitment to an asymmetry between pleasure and pain This is the thought that, although it is wrong to bring into existence a child [...]

    5. Better Never to Have Been is a tremendous philosophical work dealing with antinatalism In it, David Benatar argues for that which no one has the courage to argue for That coming into existence is always a harm and that sometimes life may not only not be worth starting but also not worth continuing The book is very well written and extremely clear You can tell that Benatar really went out of his way to make sure this was an accessible book to everyone His case is purely logical and you won t be a [...]

    6. Haven t read it, and I don t know if I will, but I m happy to have found that there are actually other people along the same line of thinking as mine.

    7. An absolute must read for anyone considering having children, either voluntarily or under duress, and for all those who are childless by choice who need to know that they are not alone Enjoy

    8. A fascinating book that stakes out a well argued if quite unusual position that given the suffering of human existence which is bad and the fact the a non existent being does not regret missing out on pleasure, it is better not to come into existence The author is careful to draw a distinction between coming into existence through being born and ceasing to exist via suicide for example He is arguing against giving birth to new children, not in favor of suicide In the course of making his argumen [...]

    9. There are a couple of times in this book when Benatar just asserts some point that he has not argued for earlier in the book One example of this is his claim that after a certain amount of pain no amount of pleasure can make a life worthwhile This seems quite wrong.He argues that because of the non identity problem coming into existence is always a bad thing This might be a problem for deontologists, but definitely not for consequentialists.He talks about how the polyanna principle makes us bias [...]

    10. Eh shrugs shoulders Shock jock philosophy that fails to be all that shocking Like a trip to the latest exploitation flick where we find out that we ve seen it all before Did I read every word No need As is typical with this type of philosophy, Mr Benatar lays out his premise and then spends the rest of the book repeating it, over and over and over Does he really believe what he writes Who knows It is sad that modern philosophy has fallen so deeply into the nihilism abyss that we literally have a [...]

    11. needs phenomenology we don t live our lives all at once for this reason, the balance sheet method to calculating whether existence is a good or an ill doesn t workat said, there s almost no good reason to bring another human being into existence on that point, he and I agree.

    12. Great quote Some know that their baby will be among the unfortunate Nobody knows, however, that their baby will be one of the allegedly lucky few Great suffering could await any person that is brought into existence Even the most privileged people could give birth to a child that will suffer unbearably, be raped, assaulted, or be murdered brutally.

    13. The author argues with Utilitarian arguments that it is better to have not been born and coming into existence constitutes a harm I studied physics as an undergrad and sometimes your model gives absurd answers because our reality is truly bizarre and sometimes it gives absurd answers merely because your model is wrong for that range of phenomena I think a misapplication of the model of utilitarianism is the heart of the problem Utilitarian calculus is great at figuring in places like public poli [...]

    14. No less essential than The Conspiracy Against the Human Race, this book lays out a broad, powerful argument against any further procreation on the basis of harm done Admittedly counterintuitive like other facts of life , the central, pro death, extinction embracing thesis is actually the most philanthropic route The sooner human suffering ends altogether, the better That said, my personal bias on the subject didn t blind me to flaws in this book, such as the almost immediate descent into psychob [...]

    15. Required reading for folks who believe that procreation is justified You don t need to be convinced by Benatar s arguments, but you should have tested yourself against them before taking up the awesome potential for harm that comes with procreation.

    16. I found this book after reading Thomas Ligotti s The Conspiracy Against the Human Race This is a far philosophical, dry text Ligotti is focused on the nightmare of being and the human condition with a focus on the curse of consciousness and it s relation to horror fiction in particular Benatar is focused on the traditional anti natalist viewpoint.I thought this was a rigorously and deftly argued book, and while Benatar realizes he isn t likely to change many minds, he feels he needs to say it [...]

    17. There are some interesting arguments in this book about the rationality of continuing to create people, but everything hinges on the idea that to exist is to be harmed It seems that because it is unavoidable that we will occasionally be hungry or a little cold or that sometimes people are murdered, we would all be better off never experiencing anything at all That seems a bit extreme and subjective to me, and I was never fully convinced of the premise but it was enlightening to follow the logic [...]

    18. A bit egocentric in its presentation all about his views although maybe that is typical for philosophy I want to stress that the 1.5 5 rating is not for the topic itself, which I think is fascinating and worth considering, in appropriate settings, but rather for the actual logic The outright refusal to make harm benefit trade offs, even in theory, is just a non starter for almost anybody who thinks about this issue Also it got a bit technical and terminology heavy at times, which at least from m [...]

    19. This book offers an extremely interesting perspective and one of the most controversial books that I have ever read The writer is extremely brave in his ideas and this attempt at publishing them It can be very offensive to most people yet though provoking if one is able to tolerate such an extreme stand on issues of existence and procreation.However, as the ideas themselves are intriguing at the least, the adopted philosophical method I believe did not do the writer much favor He has employed ra [...]

    20. This book is just plain fun Benatar is an amusing writer, not because he writes hilarious prose it s extremely clear and concise , but because he baldly states his wild conclusions in his clear, straight forward way The book starts by making an argument with which no one agrees that coming into existence is always a harm, that we ought never to bring any new people into existence , and then working through all the implications of his view that seem to count against it Spoiler alert he bites the [...]

    21. I found this book clear, thorough and persuasive Many people won t read the most important part, chapters two and three, not because they re not clear and well argued but because many people don t like reading this kind of philosophy The author states the conclusion and supporting arguments plus all the potential objections and counter arguments, which he refutes one by one This can seem tedious if you prefer a rhetorical, polemic treatment But a rhetorical, polemic treatment would be quickly [...]

    22. I am going to love this one This subject really gets me Something so true yet so controversial It speaks right to the center of our being and our nature as humans.

    23. The optimist surely bears the burden of justifying this procreational Russian roulette 3.5 stars I was irrevocably in favor of this book s conclusions a year ago I even used parts of it for my undergrad seminar Now that I ve read it through and through, I must say I m a little disappointed.First of all, the book isn t really enjoyable By this of course, I don t mean to say that I expected a happy read, but something profound, touching, shattering, anything Shouldn t it be It discusses antinatali [...]

    24. Meglio non essere mai nati, dice il sudafricano Benatar.Lo fa con un solido almeno nell intento libro di filosofia analitica, non con piagnistei di stampo continentale sul destino rio che opprime le umane genti.Attenzione, per.Il titolo pu trarre in inganno il libro non vuole difendere il suicidio, che considera solo incidentalmente, bens promuovere l antinatalismo.Benatar distingue difatti tra vite degne d essere vissute e degne d essere iniziate e fa notare come la distinzione sia gi patrimoni [...]

    25. It was hard to rate this book I can t say I enjoyed it as it was quite a difficult read, although he clearly intended it to be accessible to the layman, rather than only to those trained in philosophy and logic I admit I skimmed some sections, especially the chapter on extinction I finished the book still undecided about whether or not I accept his argument There can be no doubt, even so, that procreation should be drastically curtailed, and that it is wise to think twice before deliberately bri [...]

    26. David Benatar s thesis is a simple one, or less encapsulated in his title that it is preferable to have never been born than to suffer the unavoidable pains inherent in existence This seems, on the surface, a fairly uncontroversial statement, and one to which I or less subscribe When, however, this view is extrapolated to suggest that we should refrain from procreation and, subsequently, allow the human race to succumb to extinction, antinatalism tends to elicit disbelief from and draw the ire [...]

    27. Benatar s essential argument hinges on the following premises the presence of pain is bad,and that the presence of pleasure is good.However, such a symmetrical evaluation does not seem to applyto the absence of pain and pleasure, for it strikes me as true that the absence of pain is good, even if that good is not enjoyedby anyone,whereas the absence of pleasure is not bad unless there is somebodyfor whom this absence is a deprivation I agree with premises 1 and 2, but I m not sure if premises 3 [...]

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *